While the principle of “affordable indulgence” remains true, the specific product that benefits has changed, and the consumer’s motivation is now more complex than simple self-treating.
1. The Mask Effect: Substitution to Other Categories
The most immediate disruption was the COVID-19 pandemic, which necessitated mask-wearing and directly suppressed the sale of lipstick. Consumers still sought small luxuries, but they simply substituted the product.
- The Mascara Index: Sales of eye makeup and nail polish surged during the mask era, demonstrating that the psychological need for affordable luxury remained, but the item changed based on visibility.
- The Fragrance Index: The fragrance segment has consistently shown resilience and high growth, even as other categories slow down. Fragrance is the new “safe” splurge, offering an internal, personal luxury.
Advertisement (more below)
Black as night; slick moves. Rubberlash is a high-tech lifting mascara that stretches lashes up and out using proparietary latex lift technology. Concentrated polymers and waxes grip lashes for a better hold and sculpt lashes one by one, root to tip. Delivering up to 16 hours of smudge-proof wear, Rubberlash envelopes lashes in a flexible, glossy film with no smearing, no flaking — just major volume and light-as-air lift. Like a lash lift in a tube.
Imported
Delivering up to 16 hours of smudge-proof wear
Glossy film with no smearing or flaking
Vegan & Cruelty Free Formula
Made in Italy
2. The Rise of ‘Dermocosmetics’ and ‘Efficacy’
Today’s consumer is more educated and scrutinizes value more heavily than ever before. Spending habits show a clear preference for products that offer a tangible return on investment (ROI) for the skin, not just color.
- Skincare Dominance: Skincare is now the largest and most resilient segment of the beauty market. Consumers are selectively splurging on high-performance items like facial serums and peptide lip treatments, viewing them as necessary health investments rather than frivolous impulse buys.
- The Value Shift: Consumers will skip a $30 lipstick for a functional $35 peptide-infused lip balm, demonstrating that the purchase decision prioritizes efficacy over pure aesthetic indulgence.
3. The Dupe Culture and Price Sensitivity
The rise of social media platforms like TikTok has fueled a massive “dupe” (duplicate) culture, where consumers are actively encouraged to seek out affordable alternatives that perform just as well as prestige items.
- Erosion of Prestige: This trend directly hurts the legacy brands like MAC and Clinique (as detailed in the previous answer) whose high prices are difficult to justify when an indie or mass-market brand offers a highly reviewed, comparable product at one-third the cost.
- The New Barometer: The consumer isn’t necessarily cutting out beauty; they are simply trading down or focusing on high-growth, value-driven brands like e.l.f. Beauty.
4. The Broader Competition for “Small Luxuries”
Beauty is no longer the sole beneficiary of the “small indulgence” impulse. Today’s consumers are splitting their “treat yourself” budget across other non-essential categories:
- Food/Beverage: Premium coffee (Starbucks), craft beer, and high-end specialty foods.
- Wellness: Exercise classes, athleisure wear, and wellness supplements.
Advertisement (more below)
- Automatic Shutdown and Adjustable: This smart coffee mug warmer has 9 temperature gears, with 1-12 hour time gears to me…
- Practical Coffee lovers Gift: This smart coffee mug warmer set is practical and has a wide audience. You can give it as …
- Multi functional Coffee Cup Warmer: Our smart coffee cup warmer set can not only heat coffee, but also melt jar candles,…
The conclusion for 2025 is that the Lipstick Effect still exists in principle (the desire for a small luxury in tough times), but the “lipstick” has been replaced by a more diversified portfolio of products like peptide lip treatments, high-end fragrances, and targeted skincare. The consumer demands value and performance in addition to a pick-me-up.
*products linked to this page are helpful to the stylists that need them. We only choose the best rated products with the lowest return rates. These products are of no additional cost to you but provide a commission to this site. If you like the products, please feel free to make a purchase. Thank you 🙂
